How does school-place allocation actually work?
The equal-preference system explained. Why the order of schools on your form matters much less than parents think — and why your last slot matters more than any of the others.
Under the equal-preference system used by every English local authority, the schools on your form are considered independently, not in order. Each school ranks all applicants against its own admissions criteria — distance, siblings, faith, EHCP naming, feeder-school links — without being told where it appeared on your form. The local authority then offers you a place at the highest-preference school that has offered you one. The order only decides which offer you receive, not whether any given school offers you.
Why the equal-preference system exists
Before 2007, some local authorities operated 'first preference first' — schools were told your ranking and often prioritised parents who had put them first. That created a well-documented gaming problem: risk-averse parents put a safer school first, and children who genuinely wanted the more competitive school missed out.
The School Admissions Code, which is statutory guidance every state school must follow, replaced that system with equal preference. Since 2007-08, no school in England has been allowed to know or use the ranking you gave it. Every school looks at your child on its own criteria as if theirs was your only application.
The practical consequence is that you should list schools in your true order of preference — top choice first. There is no strategic reason to put a safer school higher than a stretch school.
How the local authority actually decides which offer you get
After each school has independently ranked its applicants, the local authority runs the allocation. It looks at every school that has offered your child a place, and gives you the one that ranks highest on your form.
So if a family applied to (in order) 1. St A's, 2. St B's, 3. Catchment Primary, and both St B's and Catchment Primary offered while St A's did not, the family receives St B's. St A's not offering doesn't hurt St B's application at all — that decision was made independently before the LA saw the list.
If none of your listed schools offer, the LA is legally required to offer a place at another school — usually the closest one with an available space. That's rarely a school you'd have wanted.
What each school actually uses to rank applicants
Every state school publishes its 'oversubscription criteria' — the ranked list it uses when it has more applicants than places. The most common criteria, in typical order, are: (1) looked-after and previously looked-after children, (2) children whose EHCP names the school, (3) medical or social grounds recognised in advance, (4) siblings currently on roll, (5) faith criteria (for faith schools), (6) feeder-school links (some schools), (7) distance from home to school.
The specific mix and order vary by school. A community primary in a suburb might weight distance heavily; a Church of England school in a diverse borough weights faith criteria heavily; a grammar school weights entrance-exam scores as the primary criterion.
Always read the specific school's admissions policy for the current admissions year — not the general 'about us' page — before assuming you qualify for a particular criterion.
The one slot on your form that matters more than the others
Order doesn't decide whether you get an offer from a given school. But it does decide which offer you receive — so your bottom slot is a genuinely important choice.
If every higher preference rejects you, the offer you receive will come from the lowest-ranked school that offered. That's often your local catchment school or a similar realistic school. So the school you list last should always be one you would genuinely be willing to accept — not a punitive 'no one would want this' placeholder.
Leaving the last slot blank on a six-slot form is almost always a mistake. If your five higher preferences all reject, the LA offers you the nearest school with capacity — which may be a much longer commute and a much worse fit than a considered sixth choice would have been.
The three questions Mumsnet asks every January (with actual answers)
Mumsnet's founder Justine Roberts has written explicitly about the fact that the same three questions reappear on the forum every year on National Offer Day, with the community's own canonical answers already baked in. Those questions and answers are:
1. 'All the schools I want are oversubscribed — what should I do?' Pick a realistic banker and put it last. Do not leave the last slot blank. Do not put a school you'd refuse.
2. 'If I put down great but oversubscribed schools, isn't the LA obliged to give us a place in one of them?' No. The LA is only required to offer *a* place — anywhere with capacity. There is no obligation to offer at one of your listed schools.
3. 'I'm going to have to put down a school I don't like — will my child be alright there?' Almost always yes. And waiting lists move — a school that felt like a compromise on offer day often looks quite different two months in, and many families move up onto more preferred schools' lists in the weeks after allocation.
What to do if none of your choices comes through
First, accept the LA-allocated place if you have one. This does not stop you from continuing to pursue better options — it just guarantees your child has a school on day one.
Second, join the waiting list for every school you preferred. Waiting-list order is set by the school's oversubscription criteria (not by application date), and movement is real — significant numbers of families decline offers in the weeks after allocation.
Third, consider whether you have grounds to appeal a specific rejection. Appeals succeed on two grounds: (a) the school didn't apply its policy correctly to your child, or (b) the difficulty to your child of not attending this school outweighs the difficulty to the school of taking an extra pupil. For Reception/Year 1/Year 2, the second ground is very narrow because of the 30-pupil infant-class cap. Appeals process at gov.uk/school-admission-appeals.
Frequently asked questions
Does it matter what order I put schools on the form?
Less than parents think. Order only decides which of your offers you receive — not whether any specific school offers you. Put schools in genuine order of preference, and make sure your last slot is a school you would actually accept.
Should I put my catchment school as my first or last choice?
Wherever it truly sits in your preference. Position on the form doesn't change your chances of an offer from any school. If you prefer another school over your catchment, list that other school first. If your catchment is genuinely your first choice, put it first.
What happens if I only list two schools instead of six?
If both offer, you get your top preference. If neither offers, the LA offers you the closest school with an available space — which may be much further from home and much less suitable than a considered third or fourth choice would have been. Use all your slots unless you're truly indifferent to any school beyond your top two.
Do private schools work the same way?
No. Private schools are not part of the local-authority equal-preference system. Each private school runs its own admissions independently, on its own timeline, with its own entry test or interview. You register directly with each school.
Can I add or change my choices after the deadline?
Not for the main allocation round. After the deadline, changes usually only apply for the in-year admissions process — which is a separate route with different timing and typically depends on whether a school has an in-year vacancy. Contact your local authority admissions team directly.
This piece explains how the system works. It cannot tell you what your specific chances are at a specific school in a specific year — for that, look at the school's published admissions statistics (furthest distance offered, applicants per place, waiting-list movement) alongside your own catchment position. Deep Teaching's assessment tools are built for the next-step decisions.
Evidence level
Sourced from the School Admissions Code (statutory guidance published via gov.uk), gov.uk school-admissions guidance and the Local Government Association's council-level admissions reporting.
References
- Department for Education. (2024). School Admissions Code ↗ external. Statutory guidance, gov.uk
- GOV.UK. (2025). Applying for a state school place ↗ external. gov.uk
- GOV.UK. (2025). School admission appeals ↗ external. gov.uk
Is it worth getting a tutor for the 11+? A data-based answer, not a guilt trip
Private tutoring has grown fast in England and Wales — 29% of secondary pupils have had it at some point, 45% in London — but that figure includes children being tutored for very different reasons. This piece walks through five questions to answer before booking a tutor for the 11+.
Does paying more buy a better outcome? What £30,000 and £50,000 a year actually get at 25 leading senior schools
Across 25 leading senior schools, published fees explain only about a third of the differences in Oxbridge outcomes. The most academically selective schools tend to be the best value per pound of fees, and one school matches a £49k-a-year rival's Oxbridge success rate at £17,274 a year less.